Top Spin Blog » John McEnroe

Dear CBS and ESPN: An Open Letter on the U.S. Open

Joe Samuel Starnes — Tue, 06 Sep 2011 20:16:58 +0000

EDITOR’S NOTE: This is a letter from my parents. They have been watching a lot of the U.S. Open.

To the producers and directors of CBS & ESPN tennis productions:

You have some of the worst announcers in sports.

I have a son who was a junior tennis player when McEnroe was beginning his career. I saw hundreds of junior tennis players who copied McEnroe’s horrible behavior — screaming, ranting, raving, cursing, acting like an out-of-control person. He had a negative influence on thousands of junior players. I have complained to the officials at many tournaments because of the behavior of junior players — behavior that McEnroe displayed for years on worldwide TV.

And now McEnroe is a spokesman for tennis. His tennis commentaries should be renamed the “McEnroe Autobiography Show.” He babbles on about matches he played thirty years ago while ignoring the current matches. He thinks he is the only person who ever played the game. Chris Fowler and Mary Carillo are just as bad. They talk about things unrelated to ongoing matches.

Jim Courier, Darren Cahill, Bill Macatee and Cliff Drysdale are very good.

You should trash McEnroe and Carillo.

Eddie and Jo Anne Starnes, Cedartown, Georgia

No related posts.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

U.S. Open Ratings Soar — Could John McEnroe Get Another Talk Show?

Joe Samuel Starnes — Fri, 11 Sep 2009 01:26:45 +0000

ESPN is touting excellent ratings, about 2.3 million viewers last night. That’s good for tennis, proving that the sport is strong enough to overcome Mary Carrillo’s idiocy and the constant babble of the McEnroe brothers.

John basically says two things about players during matches — they need to come to net more, and they need to show more emotion. He should just shout, “Play like I used to play!” I have a mental image of riding in the car with the two McEnroe brothers on the Long Island Expressway, both of them constantly critiquing how people are driving. ESPN2 would be much better off with Cliff Drysdale, who once described his own style as trying to be like the ball boys and not interfere with the match. Jim Courier and Jimmy Arias are also much more pleasant announcers. (I’m still stunned about how badly the McEnroe’s mangled the facts about Bill Tilden’s record, and U.S. Open/Championships history in general. )

My biggest worry is that this ratings success could prompt a network to give John another shot at a talk show. Here’s a promo from his short-lived show if you forgot it or missed it.

But it could be worse. Imagine if Mary Carillo got a show. Check out her obnoxious rant about Badminton from the Olympics if you want to see what she would consider entertaining.

Are these the two best people America has to talk to us about tennis?

Dear CBS and ESPN: An Open Letter on the U.S. Open EDITOR’S NOTE: This is a letter from my parents....

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

The McEnroes Bare Their Ignorance of Tennis History

Joe Samuel Starnes — Thu, 03 Sep 2009 02:17:40 +0000

In golf announcers usually know and have respect for the history of Bobby Jones, and in baseball Babe Ruth’s legend is well known. But in tennis, the history of the game is as murky to the McEnroes as the $8 beers the U.S. Open sells. Here’s a rundown of John and Patrick McEnroe’s errors when discussing Bill Tilden and tennis of that era during Roger Federer’s match on Wednesday night:

PatMac: “Tilden won six in the thirties.” No, it was 1920-1925.

Johnny Mac: “Did the winner play just one match then?” (essentially a challenge draw like Wimbledon once did and Davis Cup did until the early 70s where the defending champion automatically went to the final). No, Tilden played a full draw.

Pat and/or John (the errors were hard to keep up with): The U.S. Open was played in Boston until the thirties. No: The men’s singles moved from Newport, R.I. to the West Side Tennis Club from 1915-1920. For three of the years Tilden won the U.S. Championship, 1921-1923, it was held at the Germantown Cricket Club, a block from where he grew up in Philadelphia. In 1924 it moved to the West Side Tennis Club in Forest Hills.

Where is Bud Collins (or at least his Encyclopedia of Tennis) when they need him?

No related posts.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

With Roddick Out of Davis Cup, Fish Gets the Call

Joe Samuel Starnes — Mon, 06 Jul 2009 17:54:49 +0000

Andy Roddick’s marathon epic against Roger Federer left him with an ailing hip, forcing him out of this weekend’s Davis Cup match on red clay in Croatia. In his place will be his good friend and sometimes doubles partner Mardy Fish, who will fill the other singles along with James Blake, in the American team’s effort to beat the only nation in Davis Cup history against which the U.S. is winless (0-2) and has a losing record against.

Although there was some speculation earlier in Wimbledon by John McEnroe that Sam Querrey would make the team managed by Patrick McEnroe, Fish is the right choice with a higher ranking, a recent third round appearance at Wimbledon, and slightly better results on clay. He and Blake also reached the semis in Wimbledon in doubles.

Can Fish Turnaround the Spanish Beatdown of American Players? The matches between Spanish players and Americans at Wimbledon have...
U.S. Davis Cup: Roddick, Isner, Bryan & Bryan In his first official order of business, U.S. Davis Cup...
See You in Texas — U.S. Will Try to Avenge 0-6 Wimbledon Singles Record Against Spanish in Davis Cup With Mardy Fish’s quarterfinal loss to Rafael Nadal, the American...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

Could Wimbledon Build a Roof Over Mary Carillo’s Mouth?

Joe Samuel Starnes — Sat, 27 Jun 2009 23:17:45 +0000

It always rains heavily. And give us the option to hit the close button on John McEnroe and Brad Gilbert.

Isner-Mahut Wimbledon Rematch: What Were the Odds? According to this blog post on Wimbledon.com, the odds were...
See You in Texas — U.S. Will Try to Avenge 0-6 Wimbledon Singles Record Against Spanish in Davis Cup With Mardy Fish’s quarterfinal loss to Rafael Nadal, the American...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.